Monday, April 2, 2012

Essay #3



Robert Kidd
3/14/12
Revolvers To Automatics
            Through the 1980’s Revolvers dominated the handgun market and were the obvious choice for Law Enforcement personnel. What Changed? At some point the Police started moving towards automatics and away from the revolver. Each offer very different Pros and cons but obviously the school of thought changed and has evolved into something completely different today.  I find it very interesting that for 100 years revolvers and automatics have both existed but that in the mid 1980’s the more favored type of handgun switched. 
            First, there are some things that you should know about the different types of firearms. They are both considered “handguns” but cannot both be called pistols. They both fire cartridges that are mad up of an igniter, gunpowder, and the bullet itself.  Think of the cartridge as a bottle of champagne and the bullet as the cork. Revolvers have six “Chambers” that each holds one cartridge. These chambers are rotated when the trigger is pulled or the hammer is cocked, which in turn strikes the igniter on the cartridge in the top chamber and the gun goes off. This is repeated until all cartridges are fired and then each chamber must be reloaded individually.  An automatic however does not have any chambers. It is comprised of a handle and a “slide.” They have a detachable Magazine (Box that holds cartridges) that is inserted into the gun and cartridges are swept into the barrel by the back-and-forth movement of the slide.
            Starting in the late 1800’s revolvers were used by everyone. They were the type of handgun that was favored by Cowboys of the Wild West and also the lawmen of the era. They were seen as very simply and reliable. Back in the olden times the cartridges, which were manufactured, were often unreliable, which gave a revolver an advantage. When a cartridge fails to go off in an automatic handgun the user must grab the slide and manually pull it back in order to clear the bad round and load another into the barrel, but when a cartridge failed in a revolver all one had to do was pull the trigger again in order to rotate the cylinder holding the chambers and a fresh cartridge would be fired. This obviously was a serious advantage because it much faster to shoot again.  As time went on, however, the manufacturing process became better and better which eventually cancelled out the advantage because there were less and less cartridge failures. So once this happened they were even again in terms of recovering from a bad round.
            Then there was the question of power. Everyone wanted the most power and back in the early 1900’s revolvers could accept more powerful cartridges because of the manufacturing process. The cylinder, in a revolver, was made by drilling six holes into a single piece of metal. This was much stronger than the process for making an automatic, which was made by stamped parts held together by pins and welding. Thus the revolvers could hold up to higher pressures and were able to fire bigger bullets than autos. Once again the manufacturing process improved and automatics became equal in terms of durability.
            Finally one of the most important aspects of any firearm, which will be given to a lawman, was simplicity.  This is not to say that lawmen are simple but with the growing need for law enforcement training costs money and the faster someone could train a new officer the more cost effective a given handgun would be. Revolvers have always been seen as very simple. In reality they are comprised of more parts than an auto but in terms of training, it used to be easier to train someone to use a revolver because they were reliable and had no safety. The safety for a revolver was the holster. Also the trigger pull on a revolver is much longer and heavier than that on an auto. This means that accidental discharges were much more rare for revolver users. During the 1980’s a new gun was introduced, the Glock. It was an automatic that had no safety and was made up of plastic and metal. It beat the revolver in all categories and served as the biggest reason for the switch from revolvers to automatics. It has a long trigger pull like the revolver and actually has a safety mechanism, which keeps it from being fired accidentally. Also it holds 17 cartridges compared to revolvers which hold six.
            After researching the topic it has become clear that the idea that a simple firearm is better has been redefined. The added benefits of an automatic handgun clearly outweigh the negatives, thanks to modern manufacturing capabilities. The movement from revolvers to automatics, in hindsight, was probably inevitable because the reasons for using a revolver were mostly based on manufacturing capability. 

3 comments:

  1. I like this essay because i am into guns myself. My favorite that was in the 1900 or 1800's is the winchester, also known as "the gun that won the west". Awesome essay overall.
    check my essay out at http://eng111rnguyen.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  2. This was cool. I started liking guns more when I started watching How I Met Your Mother. One of the girls Robin carries one in her purse (to be funny) & I thought it was awesome. I would if I could I guess...if you also could please comment on my essay 3 that would be great! Thank you http://nhijazieng.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete